关于婚后财产的迷思
赶超美日 • • 52454 次浏览1. 新加坡妇女宪章
“matrimonial asset” means —
(a)any asset acquired before the marriage by one party or both parties to the marriage —(i)ordinarily used or enjoyed by both parties or one or more of their children while the parties are residing together for shelter or transportation or for household, education, recreational, social or aesthetic purposes; or(ii)which has been substantially improved during the marriage by the other party or by both parties to the marriage; and(b)any other asset of any nature acquired during the marriage by one party or both parties to the marriage,but does not include any asset (not being a matrimonial home) that has been acquired by one party at any time by gift or inheritance and that has not been substantially improved during the marriage by the other party or by both parties to the marriage.
所有婚后获取的财产（礼物或遗产除外）都是婚后财产 （法律说一次就好，不需要三次）。什么“你的是我的，我的也是我的”在法律上只是笑话。
2. 案例
－ Google “2015 Family Law – Matrimonial Assets – Division site:singaporelaw.sg”
－一个个找 http://www.singaporelaw.sg/sglaw/laws-of-singapore/case-law/free-law/high-court-judgments （离婚案例多数是缩写 vs. 缩写）
-
赶超美日 楼主#1
ARL v ARM [2015] SGHC 61
http://www.singaporelaw.sg/sglaw/laws-of-singapore/case-law/free-law/high-court-judgments/15936-arl-v-arm-2015-sghc-61
The undisputed matrimonial assets and their gross values are set out in the following table:
S/n
Matrimonial Asset
Value
1
Matrimonial Home (joint names)
$1,300,000[note: 15]
(per the Plaintiff’s valuation, which is the higher of the two)
2
The second condominium unit (the Plaintiff’s sole name)
$1,000,000[note: 16]
3
The Plaintiff’s POSB Savings Account
$2,176.75[note: 17]
(as at 21 August 2013)
4
The Plaintiff’s CPF accounts:
Ordinary Account (“OA”): $0
Medisave Account (“MA”): $37,043.24
Special Account (“SA”): $33,079.16
$70,122.40[note: 18]
(as at 29 August 2012)
5
The Plaintiff’s two insurance policies
Undisclosed surrender values
6
Nissan Latio
(on hire purchase)
$ 16,257.00[note: 19]
7
The Defendant’s POSB Savings Account
$2,194.29[note: 20]
(as at 18 December 2012)
8
The Defendant’s United Overseas Bank Uniplus Account
$9,540.10[note: 21]
(as at 1 July 2013)
9
The Defendant’s DBS Plus Account
$1,850.00[note: 22]
(as at 18 December 2012)
10
The Defendant’s CPF accounts
OA: $928.17
MA: $21,638.70
SA: $532.94
$23,099.81[note: 23]
(as at 17 December 2012)
11
The Defendant’s five insurance policies
1) NTUC Income Enhanced Incomeshield Insurance Policy;
2) Aviva Ltd My Shield Policy;
3) Great Eastern Life Whole Life with Escalating Reversionary Bonus Policy;
4) NTUC Income Mortgage Protector Insurance; and
5) Manulife Financial Life Protector Plus Policy.
Undisclosed surrender values for four of the policies.
The fifth policy has a surrender value of $120,000.[note: 24]
Gross value of matrimonial assets
$2,545,240.35
http://www.singaporelaw.sg/sglaw/laws-of-singapore/case-law/free-law/high-court-judgments/15936-arl-v-arm-2015-sghc-61
The undisputed matrimonial assets and their gross values are set out in the following table:
S/n
Matrimonial Asset
Value
1
Matrimonial Home (joint names)
$1,300,000[note: 15]
(per the Plaintiff’s valuation, which is the higher of the two)
2
The second condominium unit (the Plaintiff’s sole name)
$1,000,000[note: 16]
3
The Plaintiff’s POSB Savings Account
$2,176.75[note: 17]
(as at 21 August 2013)
4
The Plaintiff’s CPF accounts:
Ordinary Account (“OA”): $0
Medisave Account (“MA”): $37,043.24
Special Account (“SA”): $33,079.16
$70,122.40[note: 18]
(as at 29 August 2012)
5
The Plaintiff’s two insurance policies
Undisclosed surrender values
6
Nissan Latio
(on hire purchase)
$ 16,257.00[note: 19]
7
The Defendant’s POSB Savings Account
$2,194.29[note: 20]
(as at 18 December 2012)
8
The Defendant’s United Overseas Bank Uniplus Account
$9,540.10[note: 21]
(as at 1 July 2013)
9
The Defendant’s DBS Plus Account
$1,850.00[note: 22]
(as at 18 December 2012)
10
The Defendant’s CPF accounts
OA: $928.17
MA: $21,638.70
SA: $532.94
$23,099.81[note: 23]
(as at 17 December 2012)
11
The Defendant’s five insurance policies
1) NTUC Income Enhanced Incomeshield Insurance Policy;
2) Aviva Ltd My Shield Policy;
3) Great Eastern Life Whole Life with Escalating Reversionary Bonus Policy;
4) NTUC Income Mortgage Protector Insurance; and
5) Manulife Financial Life Protector Plus Policy.
Undisclosed surrender values for four of the policies.
The fifth policy has a surrender value of $120,000.[note: 24]
Gross value of matrimonial assets
$2,545,240.35
-
赶超美日 楼主#2
ARX v ARY [2015] SGHC 55
Pool of matrimonial assets as of 30 June 2012
Class of asset
Description
Value (as of 30 June 2012)
Property
Glasgow Flat
$232,464.10
Turkish Property 1
$64,728.90
Turkish Property 2
$56,286.00
Turkish Property 3
$61,914.60
Turunc Property
$70,357.50
Bank and CPF accounts
17 Accounts (see Annex 1 for an itemised breakdown)
$938,659.76
Car
Toyota Fortuner
$42,000.00
Others
Paintings, jewellery and shares (see Annex 2 for an itemised breakdown)
$9,398.37
Total
$1,475,809.24
Pool of matrimonial assets as of 30 June 2012
Class of asset
Description
Value (as of 30 June 2012)
Property
Glasgow Flat
$232,464.10
Turkish Property 1
$64,728.90
Turkish Property 2
$56,286.00
Turkish Property 3
$61,914.60
Turunc Property
$70,357.50
Bank and CPF accounts
17 Accounts (see Annex 1 for an itemised breakdown)
$938,659.76
Car
Toyota Fortuner
$42,000.00
Others
Paintings, jewellery and shares (see Annex 2 for an itemised breakdown)
$9,398.37
Total
$1,475,809.24
-
赶超美日 楼主#3
Chan Tin Sun v Fong Quay Sim [2015] SGCA 2
Matrimonial Asset
Value ($)
Monies paid into Court following the sale of 30 Dafne Street, Singapore
1,906,085.44
Husband’s CPF Account
Ordinary Account
Medisave Account
Special Account
238.22
1,500.06
12.12
Wife’s CPF Account
Ordinary account
Medisave account
Retirement account
83.04
21.61
0
Husband’s OCBC Easisave Account No. XXXXXXXX9001 (“OCBC Easisave Account”)
192,892.85
Wife’s DBS Savings Account No. XXXXXX1784 (“DBS Savings Account”)
322.19
Total value of matrimonial assets
2,101,155.53
Matrimonial Asset
Value ($)
Monies paid into Court following the sale of 30 Dafne Street, Singapore
1,906,085.44
Husband’s CPF Account
Ordinary Account
Medisave Account
Special Account
238.22
1,500.06
12.12
Wife’s CPF Account
Ordinary account
Medisave account
Retirement account
83.04
21.61
0
Husband’s OCBC Easisave Account No. XXXXXXXX9001 (“OCBC Easisave Account”)
192,892.85
Wife’s DBS Savings Account No. XXXXXX1784 (“DBS Savings Account”)
322.19
Total value of matrimonial assets
2,101,155.53
-
#4
同学....
本地判决至少有上百个。狮城帮快被你贴爆啦~ 见截图：
本地判决至少有上百个。狮城帮快被你贴爆啦~ 见截图：
-
赶超美日 楼主#5
我找的是有表格的，一目了然。这个是bug，要请猫兄debug一下。本来不[…]想研究详情，但老看到个人存款不是婚后财产，房子不是共同名下不是婚后财产之类的，这个不找案例说清楚而形成错觉后，各家庭高度戒备，高度猜疑，高度计算，非常不美妙。想研究详情，但老看到个人存款不是婚后财产，房子不是共同名下不是婚后财产之类的，这个不找案例说清楚而形成错觉后，各家庭高度戒备，高度猜疑，高度计算，非常不美妙。
-
#6
给个建议你自己总结下发帖吧。
这样贴案例，狮城帮的筒子们估计没空全部看。最后还是会一团雾水的。
你自己总结下发帖吧。
这样贴案例，狮城帮的筒子们估计没空全部看。最后还是会一团雾水的。 -
赶超美日 楼主#7
总结1. 婚姻居所（martrimonial home)是婚后财产。怕婚前房被分的就不要把婚前房当居所。
2. 其它婚后付款的房子也是婚后财产。
3. 存款，CPF，保险是婚后财产。
4. 婚后财产是按婚姻贡献划分。1. 婚姻居所（martrimonial home)是婚后财产。怕婚前房被分的就不要把婚前房当居所。
2. 其它婚后付款的房子也是婚后财产。
3. 存款，CPF，保险是婚后财产。
4. 婚后财产是按婚姻贡献划分。 -
#8
房子在一人名下的呢？也属于共同财产？也属于共同财产？
-
赶超美日 楼主#9
参照ARL v ARM [2015] SGHC 61的第2点和南洋版主昨[…]天的贴，除非婚前全款付清，仍然（部分）属于婚后财产。天的贴，除非婚前全款付清，仍然（部分）属于婚后财产。
-
#10
乱了乱了....我重新开贴讲吧我重新开贴讲吧