这个合法不？

Question

有人在我家邻居FB群里发这个
大家帮忙看看我觉着不合法

日本学生团需要本地家庭提供两晚的民宿服务。
以下是民宿日期和活动时间安排（于新加坡学校假期的期间）：
x月x日下午5点: 日本学生团抵达XX联络所，本地家庭派代表迎接学生回家。
x月xx日: 本地家庭带日本学生互动出游，自由活动，费用自付。
x月y日早上7点半-8点:本地家庭派人陪送日本学生回xx联络所。

有意提供民宿的本地家庭，请发Whatsapp、MSN、短信或打个电话联系和提供家庭资料如：家庭住址、联系人和手机号码、有几位家庭成员和他们的名字、性别和年龄、愿意留宿两位、三位或四位日本学生。

日本学校将支付民宿津贴（含餐食和留宿费)酬谢给每个本地家庭。

津贴如下（含餐食和留宿费）：两位学生$380，三位学生$520，或四位学生$660.

名额有限，请有意者尽早踊跃报名参加喔。

发讯人：xx

Accepted Answer

http://www.hdb.gov.sg/cs/infoweb/residential/renting-out-a-flat-room/renting-out-your-flat/subletting-regulations

Rental period
The minimum rental period for each tenant must be 6 months per application. You are not allowed to rent out your flat or bedroom on a short-term basis, as it may disrupt the living environment and pose security concerns for our residents.

The rental period is indicated in the approval letter, up to a maximum of 3 years if all the tenants are Singaporeans or Malaysians. The maximum is capped at 1.5 years for non-Malaysian non-citizen tenants. Non-citizens refer to Singapore Permanent Residents and foreigners. You are required to reapply for approval each time you rent out your flat or renew the application.

Unauthorised renting out of flat
Our flats are meant for homeowners to live in. The terms and conditions help ensure a conducive and harmonious living environment in HDB estates. Singaporean citizens have to meet all the eligibility conditions and obtain our written approval by submitting an online application.

We take a very serious view of unauthorised rental and will not hesitate to take action against those who flout the rules. We can impose a financial penalty or acquire the flat. Even if you have obtained approval to rent out your flat, you should conduct regular checks to ensure that the rules and regulations are met.

Answer

http://m.stproperty.sg/articles-property/singapore-property-news/hosting-a-paying-guest-it-could-be-illegal/a/64595 看到这个
这种为游客提供短期住宿收取费用是当成民宿吧民宿不用牵合约 hdb可以做民宿？那不是扰乱大家的正常生活吗每天陌生人来来往往

Answer

我没给你套帽子啊。

是我看到直接忽略啊。
来问不是心动吗？不然为什么来问？

不过我觉得让陌生人住家里其实挺尴尬的。又不方便。而且我说“劝”你别干，不是说你已经干了呀。明显你邻居早就已经投入了。

Answer

组织者有赚钱。

这种你付出大头拿小钱，中间人无脑赚大钱的事劝你别干。

日本人游学不会学校组织吗？很多学校有宿舍的。比如RI,比如国家初院

Answer

个人觉得没有不合法，
第一，非租房合约
第二，主要提供学生服务，含住宿
第二，与屋主同住，含监管意味

这个合法不？

狮城帮